Although both audits and financial due diligence (aka Quality of Earnings (QoE) analyses) involve analyzing a company’s financial information, they have different objectives, scopes, and end users.

A financial audit is an AICPA-defined formal attestation of an organization’s annual financial statements. While audits verify historical accuracy and the appropriate application of accounting standards, relying solely on a clean audit opinion during an investment decision may be shortsighted.  Unlike QoE analyses, audits are not designed to identify the issues and metrics of particular interest to buyers and sellers of a business. Understanding the critical differences between a financial audit and financial due diligence is essential for investors to mitigate risk and ensure accurate business valuation during mergers and acquisitions.

What is a Quality of Earnings Analysis?

A QoE analysis is a financial due diligence engagement that evaluates whether a company’s reported earnings accurately reflect its sustainable recurring operating performance.

Unlike an audit, which focuses on whether financial statements comply with U.S. GAAP or IFRS, a QoE analysis focuses on the economic reality of the business and the earnings that a buyer or investor can reasonably expect to continue in the near term.

Another key difference is that QoE analyses are performed on a monthly basis, typically covering the preceding two or three years plus the most recent year-to-date period. Audits are focused exclusively on annual periods and most likely do not include the most recent (and relevant) months. Although audits may provide a starting point for a potential investor’s evaluation of a company, they generally do not analyze monthly operating trends or seasonal working capital needs.

Primary objectives of a QoE analysis:

  • Determine normalized earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization (EBITDA) or operating income,
  • Identify non-recurring, unusual, or one-time items,
  • Assess the sustainability of historical earnings,
  • Understand key revenue and cost drivers,
  • Evaluate working capital trends and cash flow generation, and
  • Highlight financial risks that may impact valuation or purchase price.

Can both an audit and QoE be utilized in a transaction?

Yes, many transactions utilize both. The audit provides confidence that the historical financial statements are reliable and fairly presented. The QoE analysis goes a step further and provides insight into the underlying economics of the business and supports valuation and negotiations.

Rather than choosing between one or the other, audits and QoE engagements serve different purposes and may complement each other. An audited company can still benefit from a QoE analysis because compliance with accounting standards does not necessarily indicate that reported earnings are recurring or representative of future performance, and audits likely do not cover the most recent year-to-date period.

As an analogy demonstrating the difference between an audit and financial due diligence, imagine a close friend entrusts you to help him buy a used car. Having searched the classifieds, you find what appears to be the perfect car, and the seller provides you with a certificate from a reputable mechanic. The purpose of the certificate is to provide a certain degree of comfort that the car is roadworthy. Think of the certificate as that car’s independent audit.

Although the certificate verifying the car’s roadworthiness is nice, you may insist on performing your own “due diligence.” Personally inspecting the car, kicking the tires, and taking a test drive might make you more comfortable about your friend’s potential purchase. In fact, you may even want to hire another mechanic that you know and trust to perform a more thorough inspection. Your mechanic knows more about your specific concerns and can delve deeper into the car’s history, operational features, and maintenance record to help you decide if it’s right for your friend. The financial due diligence provider acts as a specialized consultant, similar to the second mechanic performing a more personalized deep-dive inspection.

Based on the investor’s specific concerns, the financial due diligence provider can alter the scope of the engagement to address specific key risks. The diligence provider can “kick the tires” and delve deeper into deal breaker issues and other potential areas of concern.

How Financial Due Diligence Assesses Quality of Earnings (QoE)How Financial Due Diligence Assesses Quality of Earnings (QoE)

When determining whether to invest in a business, potential investors need to ensure the purchase price aligns with the company’s actual economic value. Because businesses are often valued based on a multiple of revenue or EBITDA, financial due diligence providers focus on the “quality,” or sustainability, of the company’s earnings. Unusual or non-recurring income and expense items, over/understated assets and liabilities, post-closing cost structure changes, and the inconsistent application of accounting principles are all analyzed to adjust historical EBITDA to reflect sustainable earnings. The sustainability of a company’s revenue and EBITDA streams are not reflected in a standard audit report.

Analyzing Historical Trends and Market Drivers

Audit procedures may include analytics to understand trends and relationships over the historical period, but audit reports do not comment on the market drivers behind those trends. Financial due diligence reports address key market drivers, sales strategies, customer relationships and customer retention, and attempt to understand whether the trends reflected in the historical financials are sustainable. Financial due diligence providers also typically analyze the target’s cost structure and vendor relationships to identify potential post-transaction synergies.

Evaluating Net Working Capital Requirements for Transaction Closing

Buyers and sellers typically negotiate a “target” working capital to be delivered at transaction close. The negotiated amount is usually based on the average working capital balances over the previous twelve months, but a sophisticated buyer may also consider recent growth trends, industry conditions, the seasonality of the business, and the specific composition of working capital balances. An audit report does not provide insight into monthly working capital accounts, putting the buyer at a significant disadvantage when negotiating the working capital target to be used in the purchase agreement.

The Importance of Qualitative Observations in Financial Due Diligence

The financial due diligence provider offers critical qualitative observations derived from management interviews and operational reviews. These observations may include key findings regarding the Company’s internal structure, management and accounting team, and accounting information systems. Qualitative observations rarely appear in audited financial statements but may be just as important in helping a buyer make an investment decision.

Conclusion: Integrating Audits and Financial Due Diligence

An audit provides assurance that management has presented a true and fair view of a company’s financial performance and position in accordance with well-defined rules and procedures. For a buyer to make a well-informed investment decision, however, they should understand that an audit is a complement to, rather than a substitute for, a specifically tailored financial due diligence investigation of the investment target. The transaction advisory services team at Maxwell Locke & Ritter has performed hundreds of QoE engagements on SaaS, services, and other recurring revenue companies, assisting both buyers and sellers in their evaluation of historical operating performance.

Frequently Asked Questions

  1. What is the main difference between financial audit and due diligence?
    • The primary difference between financial audit and financial due diligence is that an audit verifies historical financial statement accuracy, while financial due diligence assesses the future sustainability of earnings based on historical financial trends and helps investors identify specific investment risks. Financial due diligence provides a deeper, customized analysis tailored to the specific concerns of a potential buyer.
  1. Why should investors perform financial due diligence beyond an audit?
    • Investors perform financial due diligence beyond an audit because audited financial statements do not analyze sustainable earnings, market drivers, or working capital needs. Financial due diligence allows for a specialized investigation into deal-breaker issues and management assumptions, which are critical for determining the actual economic value of an acquisition target.
  1. How does quality of earnings impact business valuation?
    • Quality of earnings analyses adjust historical EBITDA to reflect sustainable economic performance by removing non-recurring transactions and adjusting for accounting inconsistencies. This process ensures that the purchase price aligns with the company’s true value, as businesses are frequently valued based on a multiple of sustainable earnings rather than simple historical figures.
  1. Can an audit replace the need for financial due diligence?
    • An audit cannot replace the need for financial due diligence because audits focus on compliance and historical reporting rather than strategic investment insights. While an audit provides assurance regarding annual financial statement presentation, financial due diligence provides the qualitative and operational context necessary for a buyer to make a well-informed investment decision.

Key Takeaways

  • Financial audits verify historical accuracy and compliance with accounting standards, while financial due diligence assesses future sustainability and specific investment risks.
  • Financial due diligence providers act as specialized consultants to address unique buyer or seller concerns.
  • Quality of earnings analyses identify sustainable economic performance beyond what is captured in standard audits.
  • Analysis of working capital requirements and management forecast assumptions are core components of a due diligence investigation.
  • Qualitative observations in a financial due diligence engagement provide context that audited financial statements generally fail to include.